Response 420042363

Back to Response listing

About You

1. What is your name?

Name (Required)
Mark Goodge

2. What is your email address?

Email
mark@good-stuff.co.uk

Online voting (eg, on computers and mobile devices)

6. What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of online voting (eg, voting via the internet using a computer or mobile device)?

Comment:
There are no significant benefits. Drawbacks would include a vulnerability to fraudulent voting caused by insecurities in the relevant software, and the lack of a simple audit trail.

7. What impact, if any, would online voting have on voter turnout?

Comment:
Very little. As the Scottish referendum has shown, turnout is primarily driven by the electorate's sense of engagement with the issues being voted on rather than he available of additional methods of voting.

8. Would online voting increase the ‘digital divide’ or increase accessibility in elections?

Comment:
It would increase the digital divide, especially if reduced numbers using traditional polling stations led to their numbers being reduced. The one exception to this is that digital voting may be a suitable alternative to traditional postal or proxy votes.

Electronic voting at the ballot box (eg, using a voting machine at a polling station)

10. What are the advantages and disadvantages to using electronic voting machines in polling stations instead of paper ballots?

Comment:
Electronic voting machines would make counting the vote quicker. It may also may it more user-friendly for voters where there are large numbers of options on the ballot, or where ranked voting (such as STV) is used rather than first-past-the-post. An electronic voting machine could take voters through the process of ranking candidates step by step rather than relying on them to be familiar with the system. Against that, as anyone who has found themselves in a queue for the self-service checkouts at a supermarket can testify, there is a large number of people who seem unable to read and follow instructions on a screen. If electronic voting were to replace traditional ballot papers, polling stations would probably need more staff to be on hand to assist voters unfamiliar with the technology. There may also be privacy implications if someone was unable to use a machine without a staff member present to guide them. The other main disadvantage would be the lack of a publicly visible audit trail. Allegations of faulty voting machines in the USA affecting the outcome are not uncommon. For that reason, any electronic voting system used in the UK must not rely on closed, proprietary software. Both the mechanisms and source code must be open and freely available for security researchers to inspect.

11. Would electronic voting at the ballot box be a useful step towards online voting?

Comment:
No.